Showing posts with label CONDIMENTS/OILS. Show all posts
Showing posts with label CONDIMENTS/OILS. Show all posts

Monday, January 30, 2012

Hummus

Test date: January 2012 (blind taste test)

Tester: Michele

All products for this test purchased at Whole Foods, Trader Joe's, and Fred Meyer.

MICHELE'S OPINION: This was an interesting test to perform, because they all tasted just different enough to make me want to be sure to buy the best one in the future and avoid some others.  Lilly's was pretty gross, Trader Joe' Hummus Dip had too much raw garlic flavor for me, and Haig's tasted like plastic.  You think when you purchase any hummus you're going to get something akin to what you'd order in a mediterranean restaurant (at least that's what I thought), but you should think again.  Sabra killed the competition with just the right amount of garlic and creaminess.  That's my pick, but there were some other contenders as well.  Read on for more details on price, nutrition, and taste:

PRICE COMPARISON FOR 7-8OZ OF HUMMUS (store first, then brand):
$4.69 Whole Foods Haig's
$3.49 Fred Meyer Sabra
$2.50 Fred Meyer Athenos
$2.33 Fred Meyer Tribe Hummus
$2.29 Whole Foods Original
$2.09 Trader Joe's Smooth & Creamy Classic Hummus
$1.99 Trader Joe's Hummus Dip
$1.75 Whole Foods Emerald Valley
$1.74 Whole Foods Lilly's
$1.59 Private Selection


1. Trader Joe's Hummus Dip: This product has a raw garlic taste to it and a pretty light consistency.  Unfortunately, I found that it left a raw garlic flavor in my mouth.



2. Trader Joe' Smooth & Creamy Classic Hummus: This larger version of Trader Joe's product above has a light whipped consistency and a very light color comparatively.  It has an odd taste though, like there's a little bit of mustard in it.


3. Haig's Hummus Garbanzo Bean Meze: This product has a light color to it and an almost runny consistency.  It tastes plastic-y and acidic.





4. Emerald Valley Organic Traditional Hummus: This product has a coarse grainy consistency.  It has rich chickpea flavor and I couldn't taste a lot of other ingredients (like garlic, for example).  This product is the darkest in color of all of the options.


5. Whole Foods Original Hummus: This product has a dense consistency, nutty flavor, without much garlic taste to it.




6. Lilly's Hummus: This option tastes like plastic and has a strange applesauce-like consistency (but not that runny).  It is an all around wierd product. I wouldn't purchase it again.




7.  Athenos Original Hummus: This product has a light fluffy consistency, but it tasted like it had gone bad! It tasted fermented a bit.  I didn't see any mold or other discoloration though, and the container sell by date is May 2012, four months from now!



8. Private Selection Traditional Hummus: This option has a moist, almost runny consistency and at the same time a grainy texture (similar to brown sugar instead of chunks of chickpeas).  I detected nutty and garlic flavors, but this product was relatively bland.



9. Sabra Classic Hummus: This product has a medium dense and creamy consistency. It is very flavorful and garlicy.

10. Tribe Hummus Party Tray: This product is very garlicy and even has a bit of a sticky consistency compared to the other options.





NUTRITION INFORMATION (per serving size: 1oz/28-30grams/2 Tablespoons):

Product
Calories
Fat (g)
Sodium (mg)
Carbs (g)
Notes
 Trader Joe's Hummus Dip
 80
 4.5
 135
 7
 High carb count!
 Trader Joe's Smooth & Creamy
 80
 5
140 
 6

 Haig's
 80
 6
 80
 4
Least Salty!
 Emerald Valley
 60
 4
 110
 5

 Whole Foods
 80
 6
 140
 4

 Lilly's
 70
 3.5
 105
 7
 High carb count!
 Athenos
 50
 3
 160
 5
 Most Salty - Least Fat - Lowest Calories!
 Private Selection
 80
 7
 150
 4
 Salty!
 Sabra
 70
 6
 120
 4

 Tribe
 60
 5
 120
 4



TASTE WINNER: Sabra!

Tuesday, August 10, 2010

Balsamic Vinaigrette Salad Dressing


Test Date: August 2010


Tester: Michele


Products for this test purchased at Fred Meyer, Trader Joe's, and Whole Foods.

MICHELE'S OPINION: I have to say, fat free products absolutely freak me out. Tasting them compared to full fat products highlight how wierd they are and how obviously fake tasting. I feel a third eye growing out of my neck from all of the preservatives while I eat them. It's just not worth it, from my experience. You only live once! For the others, I guess I assumed that the specialty products would be tasty, but all had funny additional tastes like orange or mustard. For a traditional tasting balsamic vinagrette, choose the winners below. Read on for more details...

PRICE COMPARISON FOR 16OZ OF DRESSING:
$7.98 Whole Foods Annie's Natural Organic Balsamic
$5.58 Whole Foods Newman's Own BalsamicVinaigrette
$5.16 Fred Meyer Girard's White Balsamic Vinaigrette
$4.99 Whole Foods Newman's Own Light Balsamic
$4.99 Whole Foods Newman's Own made with Extra Virgin Olive Oil
$3.99 Whole Foods 365 Organic Fat-Free Balsamic Vinaigrette
$3.99 Whole Foods 365 Organic Balsamic Vinaigrette
$3.98 Trader Joe's Trader Giotto's Balsamic Vinaigrette
$3.98 Trader Joe's Fat Free Balsamic Vinaigrette
$2.59 Fred Meyer Wish-Bone Balsamic & Basil

1. Newman's Own Balsamic Vinaigrette made with Extra Virgin Olive Oil: Vinegary, peppery dressing. Full balsamic flavor. Light, almost watery consistency.


2. Newman's Own Balsamic Vinaigrette: This product tastes exactly the same as the EVOO version.


3. Newman's Own Light Balsamic: This has a very similar flavor to the other Newman's Own products, however it has a bit of a thicker consistency.


4. Girard's White Balsamic Vinaigrette:  This dressing has a thick consistency, similar to a honey mustard style dressing. The flavor is light on balsamic and has an orange zest overtone. Not overly vinegary.


5. Wish-Bone Balsamic & Basil Vinaigrette:  The basil in this dressing adds a sweetness that the other products don't have. It has a medium consistency and tastes a little bit fake, like there are filler ingredients to thicken it up.


6. Annie's Naturals Organic Balsamic:  This dressing is frankly terrible. It has a medium consistency and tastes like oil and mustard mixed together, with a vinegar aftertaste.



7. 365 Organic Fat Free Balsamic Vinaigrette:  This dressing has small chunks of something in it and a relatively thick consistency. It has a basic vinegar taste, not heavy on the balsamic. There is also a peppery taste to it.


8. 365 Organic Balsamic Vinaigrette:  This dressing is heavy on the oil, that is the first taste I get from it. The aftertaste is balsamic and it has a medium consistency. Then when I taste it again it tastes like plastic. All around not good.


9. Trader Giotto's Balsamic Vinaigrette:  This dressing has a vinegary, spicy taste with a lot of flavor. I also taste a bit of honey as a sweetener. Medium to light consistency.


10. Trader Joe's Fat Free Balsamic Vinaigrette:  This tastes really, really fake. Yuck. Plastic with a hint of gel to thicken it up.


NUTRITIONAL NOTES: (serving size: 2 tablespoons) Girard's dressing packs in the most calories per serving at 110, while the other non-light products range from 100 down to 70 (Trader Giotto's). The Trader Giotto's product also has the least grams of fat per the non-light products at 6g per serving, while the others have between 9g and 11g per serving. For the light products (Wish-Bone and Newman's Own), calories drop to between 45 and 60 and fat content is 4-5g per serving. The non-fat products have 20-25 calories per serving. As for sodium, the Newman's Own products are super concentrated with 350mg to 390mg per serving. Most of the rest of the products range from 170mg to 290mg per serving, while Annie's and Trader Giotto's products both have hardly any sodium, only 55mg or 60mg per serving.


TASTE WINNER: Any of the Newman's Own products or Trader Giotto's Balsamic

Thursday, July 29, 2010

Asian-style Salad Dressing


Test Date: August 2010

Tester: Michele and husband Marc

Products for this test purchased at Fred Meyer, Trader Joe's, and Whole Foods.

MICHELE'S OPINION: These products varied widely in terms of flavor and consistency. If you like a ginger flavor, Rikki's is for you, while if you prefer a sesame taste go for the Cardini's, Newman's Own, or Trader Ming's. I would just stay away from the Wish-Bone, Whole Foods, and Annie's Light Gingerly options. Read on for more details...

PRICE COMPARISON FOR 8OZ OF DRESSING (store first, then brand):
$3.99 Whole Foods Annie's Natural Organic Sesame Ginger
$3.79 Fred Meyer Annie's Natural Lite Gingerly Vinaigrette
$3.33 Whole Foods Rikki's Gourmet Dressing and Sauce
$2.99 Whole Foods brand Organic Ginger Soy
$2.79 Fred Meyer Cardini's
$1.99 Whole Foods 365 Ginger Miso
$1.99 Trader Ming's Sesame Soy
$1.57 Fred Meyer Newman's Own Low Fat Sesame Ginger
$1.29 Fred Meyer Wish-Bone Light Asian

1. All Natural Cardini's Roasted Asian Sesame Dressing:  This product has lots of sesame taste and a medium sweetness. The consistency is very smooth and full bodied.


2. Whole Foods Organic Ginger Soy Vinaigrette:  This product is not sweet at all and has a strong ginger flavor. It also has a miso taste to it.

3. 365 Organic Ginger Miso Homestyle Dressing:  This product has chunks of orange peel, the only product that was chunky. It is also a very thick dressing with a slightly grainy consistency. As for taste, it is not as flavorful as the others.

4. Annie's Naturals Lite Gingerly Vinaigrette:  This product has a creamy consistency and lots of vinegar in it. It has a mild ginger flavor with a hint of plastic. There is also a lightly sweet honey taste. In general it is not very Asian tasting at all.

5. Annies Naturals Organic Sesame Ginger:  This has lots of toasted sesame flavor. It has a light, relatively thin consistency and is more oily than the other Annie's product.

6. Rikki's Gourmet Dressing and Sauce, Soy Ginger:  This product has a rich flavor of miso, ginger, and soy. It tastes like the dressing you get on lettuce with your terriyaki rice bowl. Great ginger flavor. Very thick. Delicious.

7. Newman's Own Low Fat Sesame Ginger:  This product has a strong vinegar flavor with sesame oil and ginger. It is not too sweet and has a light, relatively thin consistency.

8. Trader Ming's Sesame Soy Ginger Vinaigrette:  This is also strong on the vinegar, with a light sesame and ginger flavor and a thick consistency.

9. Wish-Bone Light Asian with Sesame & Ginger Vinaigrette: This product has a thin, oily consistency and doesn't have an Asian taste. We found out that is because it is made with extra virgin olive oil! Not good.

NUTRITIONAL NOTES: (serving size 2 tablespoons) These products vary widely in terms of calorie and fat content. The products with the highest number of calories, ranging from 90 to 120 per serving, include Cardini's, Rikki's, 365 Organic Ginger Miso, and Annie's Organic Sesame Ginger. The lightest in calories (35-40 per serving) include Trader Ming's, Newman's Own, and Annie's Lite Gingerly. Fat content mirrors that spectrum, with the higher caloric product having 8g to 10g of fat per serving, while the light products contain 0g to 3grams per serving. Salt is the wild card here, with the light Newman's Own light product carrying a whopping 390mg per serving, and the Trader Ming's product on the low end at 230mg per serving.

TASTE WINNER: Rikki's, with Cardini's, Newman's Own, and Trader Ming's as runners up

Red Wine Vinegar



Test Date: August 2010


Tester: Michele


Products for this test purchased Whole Foods, Fred Meyer, and Trader Joe's.

MICHELE'S OPINION: I had no idea that these products would taste so different! But I guess that makes sense, since they're made from red wine, all brands of which do have very different tastes. Trader Joe's is going to be your cheapest bet, but Colavita is only about $0.30 more if you account for the different sizes. Read on for more details and the winners....

PRICE COMPARISON FOR 12OZ OF VINEGAR:
$3.11 Whole Foods Napa Valley
$2.69 Trader Joe's
$2.68 Whole Foods Colavita
$2.37 Fred Meyer Star Italian Kitchen
$2.07 Fred Meyer Private Selection
$2.02 Whole Foods Eden Selected

1. Private Selection Red Wine Vinegar:  Very acidic taste, not sweet and not much flavor besides acid.


2. Star Italian Kitchen Red Wine: Slightly sweeter flavor, but plastic-y and unnatural tasting.


3. Trader Joe's Red Wine Vinegar:  Medium acidity and very flavorful. The smoothest flavor of the bunch.


4. Napa Valley Natural Oak Aged California Organic Red Wine Vinegar: Tastes like a glass of wine with vinegar added, I can taste an oaky flavor and grape finish.


5. Eden Selected Red Wine Vinegar:  Tastes like you kid's grape juice with tons of vinegar in it.


6. Colavita Aged Red Wine Vinegar:  Tastes like a sweet wine with vinegar added. Nice flavor and you can tell it's higher end.

NUTRITIONAL NOTES: Amazingly (I didn't think this was legal), neither the Private Selection nor the Star products have any nutritional information, so I guess I can't comment on those. For the other four products, the calorie, fat, and other nutritional information is almost nil or zero, so I guess it's not worth commenting on those either. These four products only contain red wine or red wine vinegar, except for the Napa Valley Naturals product, which interestingly also contains something called 'organic grape must', which according to several websites is a freshly pressed grape juice.



TASTE WINNER: Instead of winners, for this test I'd just say that Private Selection, Star, and Eden were the losers. All of the others had great flavor, albeit a little different.

Thursday, July 22, 2010

Vegetable Oil


Test Date: July 2010


Tester: Michele


Products for this test purchased at Fred Meyer, Albertsons, Trader Joe's, and Whole Foods.

MICHELE'S OPINION: Let me tell you: this was absolutely a DISGUSTING taste test. You try sipping 12 different oils with a spoon and let me know what you think! Yuck. But it was a really interesting test at the same time, because I always wondered if all of these different brands tasted any different. But they don't, AT ALL. If you want a slight corn or sunflower taste, then go with those oils, but if not, then just pick the cheapest option at the store. Read on for more details:

PRICE COMPARISON FOR 32OZ OF OIL (store first, then brand):
$12.58 Whole Foods Spectrum Organic High Heat Sunflower Oil
$11.98 Whole Foods Spectrum Organic Canola Oil
$11.98 Whole Foods Spectrum Canola Oil
$7.98 Whole Foods 365 Safflower Oil High Heat
$4.25 Fred Meyer Pure Wesson Oil
$3.99 Fred Meyer Crisco Pure Canola Oil
$3.99 Fred Meyer Crisco Pure Vegetable Oil
$3.56 Fred Meyer Mazola Canola Oil
$3.56 Fred Meyer Mazola Corn Oil
$3.49 Fred Meyer Saffola 100% Safflower Oil
$3.30 Trader Joe's 100% Canola Oil
$2.53 Albertsons Shoppers Value

1. Shoppers Value Vegetable Oil:  This literally has no taste at all, but when compared to other types of oil, it has a very subtle flowery taste.

2. Mazola Canola Oil:  I can't place exactly what canola oil tastes like. It's a little like corn, with a little bit of a processed, plastic-y taste. This doesn't have much taste.

3. Mazola Corn Oil:  This has a strong toasted corn flavor.

4. Saffola 100% Safflower Oil:  Although made of a different oil, this product doesn't taste any different than the canola products.

5. Pure Wesson 100% Natural Vegetable Oil: This has literally no taste to it at all.

6. Crisco Pure Canola Oil:  This is similar to the Mazola canola oil but has a bit of a stronger flavor, mostly plastic-y. But the difference between the two is very subtle.

7. Crisco Pure Vegetable Oil: This has a bit of a flowery taste, but it is very subtle.


8. Trader Joe's 100% Canola Oil: This doesn't taste any different than the other canola products.

9. Spectrum Organic Canola Oil: This product has very little taste and is similar to the other canola products.

10. Spectrum Canola Oil: This tastes the same as the organic version and other canola products.


11. Spectrum Organic High Heat Sunflower Oil: This has a light sunflower taste.

12. 365 Safflower Oil High Heat: This basically tastes like canola oil, it does not have a flavor like sunflower or corn oil does.


NUTRITIONAL NOTES: These products all have the exact same nutritional values, including 120 calories and 14g of fat per TBSP. None have any filler ingredients besides oil. One interesting thing I learned is that 'vegetable oil' is technically soybean oil.

TASTE WINNER: No winner, no loser, it all depends on your preference for flavor.

Tuesday, July 20, 2010

Strawberry Jam



Test date: July 2010

Tester: Michele

Products for this test puchased at Fred Meyer, Albertsons, Whole Foods, and Trader Joe's.


MICHELE'S OPINION: There are a lot of subtle differences in these products, but the one that I remembered after tasting them all is the Bonne Maman product. There just a little something extra to it that is delicious. All of the 'fancier' products, such as Hero and Favorit, were also good, but to tell you the truth the Smuckers regular strawberry preserves held its own against those higher-end products. Unfortunately, the fact that it includes corn syrup is a bit of a turnoff. The only ones I wouldn't purchase again are any of the reduced or no sugar options - it's just not worth sacrificing taste to save on a few calories. Also, no need to splurge on your calorie count with St. Dalfour, which wasn't that much more amazing than the other options. Read on for more details:



PRICE COMPARISON FOR 10OZ OF JAM:

$4.53 Fred Meyer Bonne Maman
$3.99 Whole Foods St. Dalfours
$3.84 Whole Foods Mediterranean Organic
$3.81 Fred Meyer Hero
$3.49 Whole Foods Cascadian Farms
$3.24 Albertsons Favorit Swis Preserves
$3.11 Fred Meyer Smucker's Organic Preserves
$2.89 Fred Meyer Smucker's Simply Fruit
$2.69 Trader Joe’s Organic Fruit Spread
$2.58 Fred Meyer Smucker's Sugar Free with Splenda
$2.50 Fred Meyer Private Selection Oregon Strawberry
$2.50 Whole Foods 365
$1.94 Trader Joe’s Organic Reduced Sugar
$1.93 Fred Meyer Smucker's Preserves
$1.71 Trader Joe’s Fresh Preserves
$1.60 Fred Meyer Welch’s Reduced Sugar


1. Favorit Swis Preserves Strawberry: This has a very natural, wild strawberry taste and has bits of fruit in it. It is very sweet and has a medium firm consistency.



2. Smucker's Simply Fruit Strawberry: This product has a firm consistency and a mild strawberry flavor.



3. Smucker's Sugar Free Strawberry Preserves with Splenda: This product has the consistency of jello and few to no fruit bits in it. It has an unnatural sugar taste and leaves an aftertaste of preservatives in my mouth.



4. Smucker's Strawberry Preserves: This has a medium firm consistency and large fruit chunks in it. It has a warm, for lack of a better term, almost roasted strawberry flavor.



5. Smucker's Organic Strawberry Preserves:  This product has a very firm consistency as well as fruit bits. It has a light, not too sweet, strawberry taste.



6. Private Selection Oregon Strawberry Preserves:  This product has a creamy consistency to it, with small and medium sized fruit bits. It is very sweet compared to the other products.



7. Hero Strawberry Fruit Spread: This product has a very natural, fresh strawberry taste and a firm consistency. Strawberry seeds from this product get caught in my teeth, in a good way. The strawberry bits are very firm and chewy.



8. Bonne Maman Strawberry Preserves:  This product has a medium firm consistency and few strawberry bits in it. It has a nice sweet flavor and is relatively creamy.



9. Welch's Reduced Sugar Strawberry Spread:  This product is frankly gross. It has a loose, runny consistency and a fake plastic taste. Yuck.



10. Trader Joe's Organic Reduced Sugar Strawberry Preserves:  This product has a firm consistency, just under that of jello. It does not have many strawberry bits in it. It has a grape juice-like flavor. It is not that flavorful compared to the other products.



11. Trader Joe's Organic Strawberry Fruit Spread: This product has a smooth firm consistency and an almost baked strawberry flavor. It is not very sweet.



12. Trader Joe's Fresh Strawberry Preserves:  This product has large strawberry bits and tastes like a natural product. It has a medium firm consistency and is not too sweet.



13. St. Dalfour Strawberry 100% Fruit:  This product has a fresh, natural strawberry taste, with a sight bit of tartness to it.



14. Cascadian Farm Organic Strawberry Fruit Spread: This product has a looser consistency and frankly an odd taste to it. It seems to be almost an orange flavor. There are good bits of strawberry in it.



15. 365 Strawberry Fruit Spread:  This is a very smooth product with no fruit bits in it. It has a slight flavor of alcohol, surprisingly, in the form of a faint hint of something like a light wine taste.



16. Mediterranean Organic Strawberry Organic Preserves:  This product has a very loose, creamy consistency and a really nice, not too sweet strawberry flavor.



NUTRITIONAL NOTES: (serving size: 1 TBSP) The bulk of these products have between 40 and 50 calories per serving, with Smucker's Sugar Free and Welch's Reduced Sugar at the low end with 10 and 20 calories, respectively, and St. Dalfour at the high end with 70 calories. Carbohydrate levels are directly correlated with calorie level, with 5g per serving in the reduced or no sugar options all the way up to 14g per serving in St. Dalfour. Most products have 12-13g per serving. Most of the products, in addition to strawberries, pectin, and some sugar, also contain citric acid. Unfortunately, the Trader Joe's Fresh Strawberry product and the Smucker's Strawberry Preserves also contain corn syrup as the second ingredient.



TASTE WINNER: Bonne Maman Strawberry Preserves

Tuesday, July 6, 2010

Mayonnaise


Test date: July 2010

Tester: Michele

Products for this test purchased at Trader Joe's and Fred Meyer.

MICHELE'S OPINION: This test surprised me because I have always assumed that mayonnaise is mayonnaise. But that is certainly not the case. The Miracle Whip has a great zing to it for sandwiches, and the Best Foods is a good option for a less vinegar-y flavor. But if you like a not-so-sour taste, go for the Kraft Mayo product. The Trader Joe's products didn't wow me at all, but if you must buy there then choose the Real Mayonnaise product, which tastes the best out of all three. Read on for more details on price, nutrition, and taste:

PRICE COMPARISON FOR 15OZ MAYONNAISE (price first, then brand):
$3.99 Fred Meyer Kraft Mayo Real Mayonnaise
$3.73 Fred Meyer Best Foods Real Mayo
$3.49 Trader Joe's Organic Mayonnaise
$2.99 Fred Meyer Best Foods Light
$2.89 Fred Meyer Kraft Miracle Whip Light
$2.89 Fred Meyer Kraft Miracle Whip Original
$2.00 Trader Joe's Real Mayonnaise
$1.50 Trader Joe's Reduced Fat Unsweetened, Low Sodium Eggless

1. Best Foods Light Mayonnaise: This product is thick and creamy, with a nice light sour taste of vinegar.

2. Best Foods Real Mayonnaise: This product is more sour than the light version, and a bit more fatty tasting but not by much.

3. Kraft Miracle Whip Light Dressing: This is not as thick as the Best Foods products and definitely has a strong vinegar zing to it.

4. Kraft Miracle Whip Original Dressing: I can't tell any difference between this product and the Light version.

5. Kraft Mayo Real Mayonnaise: This is one of the least sour products in this test, and is not as thick as the Best Foods products.
6. Trader Joe's Real Mayonnaise: This product has a medium thickness and a very original taste: they used apple cider vinegar to flavor the mayo instead of regular vinegar. The apple cider vinegar taste is very easy to pick out.

7. Trader Joe's Organic Mayonnaise: This product is made with soybean oil like the other products, but for some reason you can taste the soybean flavor in this product, while you can't in the others. In my opinion, this makes it taste very odd. It has a very sour taste and not much creaminess to it.

8. Trader Joe's Reduced Fat Unsweetened, Low Sodium, Eggless Mayonnaise: This product looks bad and tastes just as bad. While the other products look white and creamy, this one has a yellow hue and a slight transparency to it, like a rice pudding. It tastes fake as well.

NUTRITIONAL NOTES: In terms of calories, the full fat products range from 90 to 110 calories per serving (tablespoon), while the light products and the Miracle Whip Original range from 20 to 40 calories per serving. The light products also win in terms of fat content, as you would expect, with 1.5 to 3.5 grams per serving (this includes the Miracle Whip Original product). However, the light products pack a higher salt punch though, ranging from 75mg to 130mg per serving. In the full fat products, although the fat content ranges from a whopping 10-12 g per serving, the salt content is lower, ranging from 70 to 90mg per serving.

TASTE WINNER: Best Foods Light or Miracle Whip (regular or light)

Tuesday, May 25, 2010

Baby Dill Pickles

UPDATE COMING SOON-MORE PRODUCTS, PHOTOS, ETC!

Test date: May 2010

Tester: Michele and husband Marc

Product for this test purchased at Fred Meyer and QFC.

MICHELE'S OPINION: Frankly I was surprised that none of these options were very crunchy. That's what I like best about pickles, that they have a great crunch to them (like the huge half-dills that you get at a jewish deli - delicous!). Maybe after they've been in the fridge for a bit that will change; I did the test before they'd been opened so they were all at room temperature. Read on for more details on price, nutrition, and the taste winner:

PRICE COMPARISON FOR 24OZ OF PICKLES:
$3.99 Private Selection Mild
$3.99 Private Selection with Garlic
$2.50 Farman's
$2.50 Nalley


1. Farman's Home Style Baby Dills: This product has a good vinegar flavor, but is not very crunchy.

2. Nalley Baby Dill Wholes: This product packs more of a dill punch than Farman's. However, the consistency is slightly rubbery and, Marc says, "squeakier" between your teeth than Farman's.

3. Private Selection Baby Mild Dill Pickles: This option is relatively crunchy but has very little flavor.

4. Private Selection Baby Baby Dill with Garlic Pickles: This product has a similar crunch to the other Private Selection option, but a very smoky flavor. I don't taste much garlic as the label states, just a powerful smoky flavor that lingers in your mouth.

NUTRITIONAL NOTES: Both of the Private Selection products state that they have five calories per 28g, while Farman's and Nalley state zero calories per 28g (however, the labels are quite confusing, because Private Selection states that 28g is about two pickles, while Farman's and Nalley say that's about one pickle - they all look the same size to us). In terms of salt, practially the only ingredient in these products besides the actual cucumber and vinegar, the Private Selection Mild Dill has the most, with 350mg per 28g, while the other three range from 260-290mg per serving.

TASTE WINNER: Nalley has the most original dill flavor of the group.

Original BBQ Sauce

UPDATE COMING SOON - MORE PRODUCTS, PHOTOS, ETC!

Test date: May 2010

Tester: Michele and husband Marc
Products for this test purchased at Fred Meyer.

MICHELE'S OPINION: This was a really hard test, because there is something good and bad about each of these sauces. Also, it really comes down to what type of sauce you prefer - sweet, spicy, smokey, etc. I think in the future I'll purchase Jack Daniel's again, because that's the taste I prefer. But there really is no clear winner in this test. Read on for more details on price, nutrition, and taste:

PRICE COMPARISON FOR 18-19OZ OF SAUCE:
$2.05 Bull's-Eye Original
$2.00 KC Masterpiece Original
$1.60 Sweet Baby Ray's
$1.50 Jack Daniel's Original No. 7
$1.25 Kraft Origional

1. Jack Daniel's Original No. 7 Recipe bbq sauce: This sauce has a cool meaty bbq flavor and does not taste too salty. It also has a fairly creamy texture. In our opinion this is the second sweetest product after Bull's-Eye. Marc says he can taste some whiskey.

2. Kraft Original bbq sauce: This product has a smoky flavor, and overall is a pretty straightforward sauce. But we both agree that it is a little fake tasting.

3. KC Masterpiece Original bbq sauce: This sauce is relatively spicy compared to the others, and there is a first taste of dill/tomato/onion that hits our tongues pretty strongly.

4. Bull's-Eye Original bbq sauce: This sauce is the sweetest of the bunch but is also spicy.

5. Sweet Baby Ray's Award Winning bbq sauce: This is a very peppery sauce and the most spicy of the group. But still has some sugaryness to it that stays on your tongue.

NUTRITIONAL NOTES: Sweet Baby Ray's seems like the richest sauce from a nutritional standpoint with the most calories (70 per 2TB, compared to 50-60 for the other products) and carbohydrates (17g per 2TB, compared to 12g to 15g for the other products). It is also one of two of these products whose first ingredient is high fructose corn syrup instead of tomato puree or concentrate (the other corn syrup-heavy product is Kraft). However, the Sweet Baby Ray's prduct has one of the lower saltiest contents, at 290mg per 2TB. The saltiest products are Kraft with 450mg per 2TB and Bull's-Eye wth 370mg per 2TB.

TASTE WINNER: Very hard decision, but I would say Jack Daniels or Bull's-Eye.

Sunday, July 12, 2009

Crunchy Peanut Butter


Test Date: July 2009

Tester: Michele

All products for this test purchased at Fred Meyer and Winco.

MICHELE'S OPINION: This again is a test where it really depends on what taste you prefer. My goals for this blogsite are to provide the best, most natural and nutritious foods from among all offerings at the grocery store, and with that mandate, I highly recommend the Adam's (which is also my personal favorite). However, if you grew up eating peanut butter with sugar in it, then go for it. The only real drawback is that the sugary products are higher in sodium, but not by much. Read on for more details on price, nutrition, and taste:

PRICE COMPARISON FOR 28OZ OF PEANUT BUTTER (store first, then brand):
$3.99 Fred Meyer Adam's
$3.00 Winco Skippy
$2.88 Winco Jif


1. Skippy: This peanut butter has a very creamy base with big chunks of peanuts all throughout. It has a slightly sweet flavor.

2. Jif: This brand of peanut butter tastes almost identical to the Skippy brand. The only difference, mildly discerable, is that Skippy may be slightly saltier than this product. But they really are amazingly alike. After tasting the two I even took a second look at the jars to see if they were made by the same manufacturer!

3. Adams All Natural: This peanut butter is totally different from the first two. Since it is all natural, there is a layer of peanut oil at the top that must be mixed in before the first serving can be eaten. It tastes like real peanuts and nothing else. It has a similar level of crunch as the others, but the base of the peanut butter is grainier than the two above because it is just ground up peanuts.
NUTRITIONAL NOTES: These three products have similar nutritonal information per 2TB, including calories (190-200), fat (16g) and protein (7g). The one big difference is the amount of sodium: Adam's has 90mg of sodium compared to the other two products, which have 120-130mg per serving. Also, the second ingredient in the Skippy and Jif products is sugar, while Adams has no sugar at all.
TASTE WINNER: I'm partial to natural flavors, so I have to go with Adam's.